Last week we observed the 10th anniversary of the attacks on September 11.
As someone who was living in New York City on that day, who stood on Fifth Avenue with countless other Midtown cubicle dwellers and messengers and deli workers, wondering at the burning towers, who bore witness to mass murder with the rest of her city...
...the anniversary stirred up an unexpected well of emotions in me. I thought I had moved past most of that sadness but it hit me harder than I thought. And I didn’t even lose anyone—I reacted as a New Yorker, an American, and a human being.
There are so many approaches to history—political theory, social theory, et cetera. But as I told one of my classmates at Columbia, I’m an actor and to me, history is first an aggregate of people's lives. The collective narrative of all of us.
There were these flyers that sprang up almost immediately all over the city. "Have you seen...?" "Missing..." You had to stop to read them. But carefully. You didn't want to start crying again on the streets. Which we were all doing anyway, on the streets, walking to church, at your cubicle. But I would read these flyers when I could. I felt I had to, to bear witness. The least I could do was learn these peoples' stories.
Visit Pompeii and see the graffiti scratched into the wall by a bored centurion millennia ago,
now carefully notated and photographed by archaeologists. Every cathedral, every bridge, every pyramid, every Book of Kells and Bayeux Tapestry, all the opera magna we take for granted were put together with the collective hands of millions of men and women exactly like us, who each had their own story to tell, to question, to live. They cared about their children and worried about the future and struggled with the larger stones and swore when they made mistakes etching calligraphy onto the vellum.
I still remember some of the faces on the flyers--one was an Asian man, a businessman, "last seen at Windows on the World.*" I remember thinking, what a beautiful, hopeful name...Windows on the World. Who wouldn't want to be there on such a gorgeous morning?
There was a young black woman, whose relatives implored anyone with information to call the number below, "We're very worried about her!!!" Oh, God. That last...
It just breaks your heart.
I remember reading about a young woman, 20s, dark blonde hair with an unusual name that jumped out at me...Giovanna.
History's deconstructed essence, its atom, is one person’s story. StoryCorps is an oral history project, dedicated to capturing Americans' lives on tape. They have interviewed several relatives of 9/11 victims and animated the results.
When you think you can bear it, go to the StoryCorps site and watch some of the videos. Past the sadness and grief, there is just so much love.
To Giovanna--
I remember seeing your pretty face in the flyers posted all over Midtown after that day.
Your name stuck with me--such a beautiful, old country name.
It's obvious your family loved you very much, I saw your flyer everywhere.
Bless you, dear one.
Your name stuck with me--such a beautiful, old country name.
It's obvious your family loved you very much, I saw your flyer everywhere.
Bless you, dear one.
There is something f/u about technology enabling people to call loved ones and say goodbye, but not being able to save them or prevent their pointless demise--it's like we as a human race are so smart, but so stupid. Those last phone calls were so precious, but -- damn! Imagine how helpless that would feel! The 2000s seem to have been fraught with such grief: terror, storms, floods, fires, BP, tidal waves ... I just hope we do not become so inured as to cease to feel just out of self-preservation. Maybe that explains the so-called "compassion fatigue" that has made so many people quit giving to charity and roll back human progress to Dickensian non-chalance. Did you hear this on NPR? http://www.wbur.org/media-player?url=http://onpoint.wbur.org/2011/09/21/hal-holbrook&title=Actor+Hal+Holbrook&pubdate=2011-09-21&segment=2&source=onpoint The pertinent part starts at 11:02. I suppose for every pendulum swing one way there is an equal and opposite reaction that I pray comes soon and will not be too bloody.
ReplyDeleteVida--As for last calls, this:
ReplyDeletehttp://nymag.com/news/9-11/10th-anniversary/good-byes/
will wreck you.
If giving to charities has scaled back recently, I would guess it's mainly because of the economy, although it certainly cannot be denied that there's a very vocal element in this country that fetishizes selfishness. But I'd like to think that when people get back on their feet they can remember back to when they needed help and extend compassion.
I'll check out the NPR link later.